Given in memory of Arthur S. Roberts, Commodore in 1956.
| 1975 | Whitney Cooper | 1994 | Tim Sheffield |
| 1976 | Stewart Cooper | 1995 | Cyrus Philbrick |
| 1977 | John Hellier | 1996 | Pete Canning |
| 1978 | Nancy Conley | 1997 | David Andrias |
| 1979 | Christopher Clark | 1998 | Sarah Evenski |
| 1980 | Avery Lee | 2001 | John Hickey |
| 1981 | Amy Repko | 2002 | Shepard Hallberg |
| 1982 | John Totolis | 2003 | Alex Riley |
| 1983 | Avery Lee | 2005 | Will Foster |
| 1984 | Joshua Bordes | 2006 | Noah Sutter |
| 1985 | Katie McGee | 2007 | Jackson Hallberg |
| 1986 | Jamie McGee | 2014 | Hannah Seehaus |
| 1987 | Katie McGee | 2015 | Liam Gronda |
| 1988 | Trevor Anderson | 2016 | Teague McMillan |
| 1990 | Chris Conley | 2017 | Henry Hardaway, Connor Foley |
| 1991 | Emily Carey | 2018 | Hughie McGee |
| 1992 | James McNamara | 2019 | Kelly Turley |